Vulturepreneur
When your struggle is their business
Miss a payment and the fee lands before the reminder does. The one-click sign-up turns into a phone queue the day you try to cancel. And when you ask for help, there's a firm waiting to sell you the way out. Some companies earn more when the customer is struggling, and a good few of their founders are on podcasts explaining how you could do it too.
This book puts one question to any of them:
Does it earn more when your life gets better or when it gets worse?
The answer is usually in their own accounts, and that's where this book goes looking.
Listen to an introduction
A minute from Natasha Cecil on the question the book is asking.
Read the transcript
You see them on podcasts all the time. Successful entrepreneurs talking about how they made their millions, how they built their businesses, and how you can do the same.
Then there are the boardrooms, where directors present another impressive set of results to shareholders. Profits are up, margins are healthy, and everyone seems pleased.
But I'd like to know a bit more about where that money comes from.
Take the companies buying people's debts and chasing them for payment. Or the insurers whose customers discover how difficult it can be to make a claim. Some companies make it ridiculously easy to sign up, then put you through a phone queue when you try to leave.
Making a profit is perfectly reasonable. But how much of that success depends on customers having very little choice?
I've been looking at company accounts, customer complaints and what the regulators have found. I'm also looking at the businesses doing things differently, and what people can do when they find themselves dealing with the others.
Because I think we should be asking a lot more questions about how some companies make their money.
Does a company earn more from you when your life gets better, or when it gets worse?
Does the company earn more from you the fewer options you have?
A credit union earns when you pay the loan back. A payday lender earned from the rollover and the default fee, until the regulator capped both in 2015 and most of the industry left, which tells you where the money was. You can put the same question to any company, and the answer is in the accounts it files, the Ombudsman's figures and the pattern of its reviews.
The fewer choices you have, the more some of them make, which is why the 27p tin of beans is the one the small store doesn't stock at five o'clock on a Sunday.
Some of these businesses have come to depend on the problem they say they solve. An enforcement firm paid per visit needs the visits, and an insurer whose margin sits in refused claims needs the refusals.
A bridge wants you across
A bridge gets paid when you get across, so it does best when you don't need it again.
A trap wants you on it
A trap gets paid when you can't get off, so it does best when you stay where you are.
You kept the emails, and they still said you'd agreed to it
The claims line that never picks up saves the firm money on every caller who gives up, and the letter saying the fee doubles on Friday was printed before you'd missed anything. This book puts names to those patterns and gives you a test to run before you sign. It takes about ten minutes when the firm publishes its numbers, and a firm that won't has answered the question already. You don't need to be interested in business to recognise any of this.
What's inside
See the chapters
The man with the lavalier mic
The founder in the podcast chair tells the origin story and gets to the part about giving back, and the chapter asks what entrepreneurship was supposed to involve.
Better or worse
This chapter sets out the test and runs it on a real company from its accounts, the Ombudsman's figures and its reviews, which takes about ten minutes once you know where to look.
The angry minority
Only unhappy people post reviews, and this chapter shows why that makes no difference once you compare a firm against its own sector on the same platform.
Sunday at five o'clock
Some companies only need you to be out of options, and this chapter prices having nowhere else to go, from the small store with no budget range to the blazer sold in one shop, ending on 'if you don't like it, don't buy it'.
Buying the debt
Old debts are sold in bulk for a fraction of what's owed, and this chapter follows one from the day it was sold to the default judgment.
Knock knock
Enforcement agents add a fixed fee at each stage, so the firm earns most when somebody turns up at the door, and this chapter sets the fee schedule beside the number of debts councils send out.
Insured until you claim
Phone insurance pays out a small share of what it takes in, and this chapter goes through the refurbished replacement, the exclusion nobody mentioned and the claims process built to be abandoned.
Four easy payments
Buy now pay later, catalogue credit, rent-to-own and subprime car finance all say interest-free on the sales page, and this chapter follows a sofa from its sticker price to what it had cost by the end.
The ones that look like help
Debt management firms, IVA mills and claims companies advertise as rescue, and this chapter is about what happens after you call.
The dream for sale
Coaching programmes and masterminds sell the method itself, and the founders in this chapter are quoted in their own words, with the dates.
Designed to confuse
The till screen asking for 10p, the subscription you can leave in nine clicks, the queue you can pay to skip and the duty free you can't walk round are the same trick in different buildings, named here by someone who builds screens for a living.
Tax on tax
A tax return filed a year late carries £1,600 in penalties whether you owed £1,000 or nothing, and this chapter asks who those penalties land on and what it takes to appeal one, before turning to the council tax bill that falls due in full after one missed instalment.
The referee's wearing their shirt
The regulators keep falling short, and this chapter explains the mechanics, from fines that come to a fraction of the profit to watchdogs funded by the firms they oversee.
The ones that pass
Plenty of companies earn more when you do better, starting with credit unions, and this chapter is a short list of the kinds of business where the incentive runs the right way.
Fighting back
This is the practical chapter, with the traps to avoid before you sign, what to do once you're already caught, how to write a complaint that gets upheld, and where the free help is.
Becoming an entrepreneur
If you want to start a business, this chapter is about building one that earns when its customers do well, with a simple way to check an idea before you spend anything on it.
What actually changes it
The last chapter makes one claim, which is that what changes these companies is information travelling faster than their marketing.
Read an extract
From the book. Chapter and title to follow.
Extract text goes here.
Send me the complaint nobody listened to
If a company has ever told you, politely and in writing, that it was all in the terms you agreed to, I'd like to hear what happened.
Every submission, if used or just read, will be kept anonymous.
Stories are stored by the site's host, read only by me, and used for nothing but this book.
Some of the terms in the book
Show the terms
- Distress-dependent revenue
- This is income that rises as the customer's situation gets worse, which is what a late fee, a rejected claim or a rollover charge amounts to. The book's one test asks whether a company's revenue has this dependency, and chapter 2 shows how to read the answer off public evidence.
- Bridge and trap
- A bridge is a business that gets paid when you repay or when your claim is met, so it does best when you get across, while a trap gets paid when you don't. Both exist in the payday lending data, since Morse (2011) found that access to short-term loans reduced foreclosures after disasters, Melzer (2011) found it made households more likely to fall behind on rent and bills, and UK credit-file data in Gathergood, Guttman-Kenney and Hunt (2019) showed a short gain followed by more borrowing and more defaults.
- The poverty premium
- This is the extra that low-income households pay for the same goods and services. The University of Bristol's Personal Finance Research Centre put it at an average of £380 a year in 2026, up from £217 in 2022, with 95 per cent of the households surveyed paying at least one premium (Evans and Davies, for Fair By Design, 2026).
- Predatory inclusion
- This is the name for being let in to a market, to credit or to a product on terms that make the letting-in itself the harm. Seamster and Charron-Chénier (2017) coined it for student debt, and it transfers directly to subprime car finance, rent-to-own and buy now pay later.
- Phishing equilibrium
- Akerlof and Shiller, two Nobel economists, argue in Phishing for Phools (2015) that competitive markets reward sellers who exploit gaps in knowledge and psychological weak spots, and that competition locks this in instead of competing it away. It's the reason the book treats these companies as a predictable product of the market and not as a few bad apples.
- Shrouded charges
- These are add-on fees that survive even fierce competition, because no rival can profit from educating customers about them (Gabaix and Laibson, 2006), and the excess and the late fee both live here.
- Sludge
- Sludge is the friction that stops people getting what they're entitled to, such as the claims line that never answers or the form that needs a document you don't have. Richard Thaler named it in 2018, and Cass Sunstein (2022) showed it falls hardest on the people with least slack.
- Dark patterns
- A dark pattern is interface design that steers you towards the choice the seller wants. A crawl of 11,000 shopping sites found 1,818 of them, with 22 third parties selling them as a service (Mathur and colleagues, 2019), and in a controlled test even mild ones doubled take-up of a paid add-on, with less-educated people more affected (Luguri and Strahilevitz, 2021).
- Calculated misery
- This is Tim Wu's name (2014) for a business that keeps its basic service uncomfortable so that the upgrade sells, which is how the airline seat works and the queue you can pay to skip. The seller controls the problem it's selling the way out of, so the worse the queue, the more the pass is worth.
- Debt purchase
- Debt purchase is the buying of old debts in bulk for a fraction of their face value, after which the buyer collects the full amount. The largest study, by the US Federal Trade Commission (2013), found buyers paying about four cents per dollar. In England and Wales the most common new consumer county court judgment in 2025 was for £283 (Registry Trust, 2026), and 87 per cent of county court judgments are default judgments, where nobody turned up to defend (Civil Justice Council, 2018).
- Enforcement fees
- These are the fixed fees an enforcement agent adds at each stage of collecting a debt such as council tax. Citizens Advice (2019) found that 62 per cent of enforced debts went past the first and cheapest stage, and modelled profit margins of up to 27 per cent, which is what a fee schedule that rewards escalation looks like in numbers.
- The late filing penalty
- A self assessment return filed late costs £100 on the day, £10 a day after three months up to £900, then £300 at six months and £300 at twelve, and since the cap tying the fine to the tax owed was removed for returns from 2010, it's the same £1,600 whether you owed £1,000 or nothing. Over four years, 420,000 of the £100 penalties went to people earning below the personal allowance, about two in five of all of them, and another 150,000 people were charged and then had it cancelled on appeal (Tax Policy Associates, from HMRC's own data, 2023 and 2024).
- Claims ratio
- The claims ratio is the share of premiums an insurer pays back out in claims. The Financial Conduct Authority's value measures data for 2025 shows gadget insurance paid out 36 per cent, down from 42 per cent the year before, and the regulator put the fall down mainly to higher premiums (FCA, 2026).
- Debt packagers and referral fees
- Debt packagers were firms that advertised as debt help and were paid for referring people into an Individual Voluntary Arrangement. The FCA found a median referral fee of £940 and IVAs costing £3,650 or more over their life, where a Debt Relief Order cost £90 at the time, and it banned the fees in 2023 (FCA PS23/5). The £90 DRO fee was scrapped in April 2024, after which DROs rose by 78 per cent (Insolvency Service, 2026).
- Uphold rate
- The uphold rate is the share of complaints the Financial Ombudsman Service decides in the customer's favour, and it's published for each firm with 30 or more complaints every six months. The book reads it alongside reviews, because most problems never become a complaint at all, and among the people who had a problem and didn't complain, between 46 and 67 per cent said it was too difficult or that nothing would happen (FCA Financial Lives 2024).
- The J-shaped review curve
- Online reviews pile up at five stars and one star with little in between (Hu, Zhang and Pavlou, 2009), and how extreme the curve is varies from platform to platform (Schoenmüller, Netzer and Stahl, 2020). That bias is shared by every firm on the same platform, which is why the book compares a company against its sector peers there instead of reading a score on its own. Invited reviews complicate the picture, because asking customers to review brings in the moderately satisfied middle (Karaman, 2021), which means a firm that only sends the invitation after a successful sale is choosing its sample rather than faking it.
- Breathing Space
- Breathing Space is the Debt Respite Scheme in England and Wales, a legal pause of up to 60 days on most interest, fees and enforcement while you get debt advice. StepChange's first-year findings (2022) showed it works but needs watching, since 37 per cent of users still had charges added during the pause.
- Section 75
- Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 makes your credit card provider jointly liable with the seller for a purchase between £100 and £30,000, so you can claim from the card company when the seller won't put things right.
Questions people ask
What is the book about?
It's about companies whose business model earns more when your life gets worse, and the founders who call that entrepreneurship, and it gives you one test to run on any company and what to do if you're already inside one.
Does it name companies?
Only where a regulator, a court or the firm's own accounts have already made a public finding, or where a person said it themselves on a podcast or a stage, and everywhere else it describes the mechanism, because that's what you need to spot the next one.
When is it out?
There's no date yet, because the stories that open each chapter are being gathered now, and if you leave an email address in the paperback section you'll hear first.
Can I send a story without giving my name?
Yes, the email box is optional and only there so I can ask before using your story, and anything printed is anonymised with the identifying details changed.
Will it ship outside the UK?
It's UK addresses only to begin with, the same as the first book, and if you leave your email you'll hear when that changes.
Is it legal or financial advice?
No, it explains how these businesses work and where the free help is, and for your own situation Citizens Advice, StepChange and National Debtline are free.
Also by Natasha Cecil
You're Not Paranoid, You Just Work Here
The unwritten rules of work, and what to do when they're used against you.
The staff survey comes back glowing, but nothing changes. Someone raises a concern, and suddenly they're the problem. A performance improvement plan is presented as support, although everyone suspects where it's heading.
There's a name for much of what goes on in workplaces, and some of it has been studied for decades.
You're Not Paranoid, You Just Work Here examines 44 workplace mechanisms, including the ones employers would rather not discuss. It looks at the research behind them, how they operate and what you can do when you recognise them.
The paperback
How the pre-order will work
Payment is taken by Stripe when pre-orders open, UK postage is included, and your copy is posted once the first print run has been checked, with a full refund if you cancel before it goes out.
Until there's a print date, the honest thing is to take an email address rather than money.
Before you sign anything, ask whether the company earns more when your life gets better, or when it gets worse.
Tell me when pre-orders openPayment, when it opens, is taken by Stripe. This site has no cookies or tracking, its two forms are read only by me, and nothing here is legal or financial advice.